Shemini: Respecting the Sanctity of Life, by Rabbi Miriam Midlarsky Lichtenfeld

Back in my teen years, at our pre-Prom gathering at my friend’s house, I didn’t eat any of the shrimp cocktail that she had put out for us to eat. She praised my self-discipline. To me, though, this seemed natural as it was an essential part of our religious tradition. 

One thing that defines us as Jews is the requirement to give thought to what we put in our mouths. This act of restricting our eating can help us work towards creating a world where we show respect for the sanctity of life helping create an ideal expressed in the Torah. 

Originally, the Torah’s ideal was for us to be vegetarians. In the creation story, humans are only allowed to eat fruits and vegetables:

“God said, “See, I give you every seed-bearing plant that is upon all the earth, and every tree that has seed-bearing fruit; they shall be yours for food.” (Genesis 1:29)

The Torah later compromises by allowing us to eat meat. As imperfect beings who also need protein, God permits us to have meat. Yet, since eating requires the act of taking another’s life, restrictions are put upon what animals we are allowed to eat. 

Our parsha, Shemini, lists the restrictions for what animals we are permitted to eat, and the more complex the life form, the more restrictions are put in place. So, the simplest life forms — fruits and vegetables — have no stipulations. Fish have only one restriction — that they have fins and scales. By contrast, the most complex level of life — cattle, sheep, etc. — have the most constraints. They must chew their cud, have cloven hooves, and be slaughtered using shechita or ritual slaughter (ensuring a quick and painless death). 

These laws teach us that respecting the sanctity of life should be our highest ideal. One way to do so is by restricting when we take a life to sustain ourselves. When we do take a life, we should do it in the kindest and least impactful way. Shmita is an even further level of kashrut, applying (in Israel) another restriction: to not farm the land that year. Thus, in Israel, one also needs to think about how they get their fruits and vegetables. Although we don’t have that requirement here, the Shmita year is a time when we can rededicate ourselves to the mission of assessing our diet for how well we honor the sanctity of life as well the impact we make on the planet.

I challenge us all to think of ways to work to live up to this ideal. In order to sustain ourselves, we have to take the lives of others (even if we are vegetarian). Let us all think carefully before we eat about whether we are choosing foods that honor that sanctity. We can do so by considering how animals are treated throughout the supply chain and how the fruits and vegetables we eat are farmed, along with the impact these decisions have on our planet. We can also try to grow more of our own food, and dedicate ourselves to eating less meat. When eating meat, we should try to commit to only eating humanely raised and processed foods. We may know that all lives on this earth are sacred and that we need to be kinder to the earth, but in the business of life, it is easy to allow convenience to reign supreme. Shmita offers us a reminder to re-evaluate and rededicate ourselves to these higher ideals. In doing so, we will remind ourselves of the sanctity of all lives and help to create a more ideal world.

Get this content delivered right to your inbox! Subscribe to our Jewish Learning email list here.

miriam lichtenfeldRabbi Miriam Midlarsky Lichtenfeld is a seasoned Jewish educator who has taught at camps, day schools, run religious schools and educated adults. She always tries to weave environmental education into her teaching wherever she is. Rabbi Miriam is currently the education director at the Orangetown Jewish Center in the suburbs of New York City. When she isn’t educating students or spending time with her family, she loves to hike with her dog, bike, read and garden.

Shmita Friday is just one piece of a large conversation that has been ongoing for a long time! We’d love to hear what you think – post a comment below, join our facebook group, and start talking about shmita with your friends and family.

2 Responses to Shemini: Respecting the Sanctity of Life, by Rabbi Miriam Midlarsky Lichtenfeld

  1. Cheryl Ratner April 10, 2021 at 1:06 am #

    Thank you for a provocative article. As an ethical vegan, I can relate to the spiritual aspects of food, the universe and G*D

  2. Jill Hekkanen June 20, 2021 at 1:01 pm #

    I am a vegetarian. Taking the time to think about what I eat, how fortunate I am to have choices, and how I love to share with others makes food holy. Sharing with others has the same good effect.